
Someone asks what your book is about, and you freeze.
You start a sentence, abandon it, start another, and three rambling minutes later you have somehow said both too much and nothing at all.
Almost every writer I know has struggled with this question, and I think part of the problem is that we hear it as the wrong question.
Your elevator pitch is not meant to explain what your book means. It is meant to tell someone what happens in it, in the shortest possible way.
Once you separate those two things, the whole task gets easier.
What They’re Actually Asking
When somebody at a party or writing conference asks what your novel is about, they are asking for the story.
Who is it about? What do they want? What makes getting it difficult?
They are not asking you to explain your themes or articulate what you are trying to say about the human condition. That deeper question matters, but this is not the moment for it.
Your elevator pitch is the part you can say in thirty seconds in an actual elevator.
Give Them the Plot
Picture the real scenario.
You are at a writing conference. You step into an elevator and somebody says, “Oh, you’re writing a novel. What’s it about?”
You have maybe thirty seconds.
What you want ready is the shape of the story: a particular person wants a particular thing and runs into a particular problem.
That is the spine.
Maybe your protagonist has to make an impossible choice. Maybe the one person standing in their way is somebody they love. Maybe circumstances force them to do the very thing they have spent the entire book avoiding.
Tell me that.
You do not need every subplot or six different characters. You definitely do not need to explain what the book says about grief, motherhood, ambition, capitalism, or the nature of being human.
Give the story first.
If you say your sentence or two and the person lights up and says, “Tell me more,” wonderful. Now you are having a conversation.
But if they just say, “Oh, cool,” you have still done the job.
Say Your Elevator Pitch Out Loud
One of the biggest mistakes I see is treating the pitch as something you write down and read.
Don’t get me wrong. Writing it out is a great first step. It helps you figure out which pieces actually matter. But a pitch becomes useful when you can say it naturally, the way you would tell a friend about a movie you loved.
And yes, practicing it feels awkward.
Do it anyway.
Stand in front of the mirror and ask the question out loud: “So, what’s your book about?” Then answer the question, out loud.
Say it in the car. Say it while you are making coffee. Say it to another writer.
And when you do get bold enough to say it to another human, watch how they react. If their eyes glaze over at some point, it’s probably too long. That’s good data. Next time, shorten it up a bit and watch for any subtle signs of enthusiasm or boredom.
Every time you pitch it, pay attention to how it lands and adjust for next time. Because there will always be a next time.
The Pitch Makes a Promise. Page One Has to Keep It.
A good elevator pitch makes someone think, “I want to read that story.” Your opening pages are where you have to deliver on that pitch to an agent, editor, or reader.
That is exactly what I’m teaching in my free class – Hooked From the Start: Crafting a Captivating First Page. We’ll look at what makes an opening page pull someone into the story and make them want to keep reading.
If you’re working on your opening and want to dig into it with me, I’d love to have you join us.
Being a complete introvert, all I can hope for is not passing out.
But I will read this post repeatedly and practice a script with my wife until I spit it out clean (and neat).
Thank you!
Glenn, practicing with your wife sounds like a great plan! And you don’t have to get it perfect. Just clear enough to make someone curious about your story.
Thank you for offering this course.
I am exactly the writer you described above. And even when I felt confident with my 2 sentence pitch, I didn’t practice it aloud, so when the moment came I stuttered, and froze, then rambled. Total disaster. Obviously, I didn’t get a request for the manuscript. This has happened more than once. Nervous adrenalinitis!
“Nervous adrenalinitis” made me smile, though I know those moments must have been frustrating. It’s one thing to have your pitch figured out in your head and quite another to say it with someone standing in front of you. I hope practicing out loud makes the next time a little easier.